10 Park Place. Butler, NJ 07405973.492.8400 biosdrycal@mesalabs.com
  • enEnglish
FacebookTwitterYouTubeLinkedinWebsite
DryCalDryCal
DryCal
Gas Flow Calibrators
  • Products
    • Defender 510 & 520
    • Defender 530+
    • FlexCal Series
    • DryCal Metrology Series
      • DryCal 800
      • DryCal 1020 & 1500
      • Integrator Pro
      • Gas Flow Benches
    • DryCal Rental Program
      • Defender/FlexCal Calibrator Rentals
      • DryCal Metrology Series Rentals
    • DryCal Pro Software
    • Other Mesa Products
  • Calibration & Repair
  • Industries
    • Instrumentation Manufacturing
    • BioPharma
    • Metrology Labs
    • Industrial Hygiene
  • Documents & Resources
    • Documents & Manuals
    • Blog
    • Product Registration
    • FlowLines Newsletter
    • Videos
    • FAQs
    • Related Links
  • Shop Online
  • Contact
    • Contact Us
    • Find a Distributor
 
  • Products
    • Defender 510 & 520
    • Defender 530+
    • FlexCal Series
    • DryCal Metrology Series
      • DryCal 800
      • DryCal 1020 & 1500
      • Integrator Pro
      • Gas Flow Benches
    • DryCal Rental Program
      • Defender/FlexCal Calibrator Rentals
      • DryCal Metrology Series Rentals
    • DryCal Pro Software
    • Other Mesa Products
  • Calibration & Repair
  • Industries
    • Instrumentation Manufacturing
    • BioPharma
    • Metrology Labs
    • Industrial Hygiene
  • Documents & Resources
    • Documents & Manuals
    • Blog
    • Product Registration
    • FlowLines Newsletter
    • Videos
    • FAQs
    • Related Links
  • Shop Online
  • Contact
    • Contact Us
    • Find a Distributor

TAR or TUR: What’s the Difference?

July 21, 2016Gas Flow Calibration BlogBy Brandon Hansen

TAR or TUR

Test Accuracy Ratio (TAR) and Test Uncertainty Ratio (TUR) are common measurement risk assessment tools used in metrology. TAR is commonly defined as “Accuracy of the Device under Test (DUT) / Accuracy of the Standard”. It is most used early in the design of a calibration system to qualify a measurement standard’s capability to provide the accuracy desired.

The primary limitation of using TAR for measurement risk decisions that users should be aware of is that the definition does not capture uncertainty influences from the unique calibration system and processes used in each user’s lab.

A standard’s accuracy specification is ultimately based on operating within a set of assumptions (commonly defined by the standard’s manufacturer). In a flow calibration, such limits may include a specific flow range, an operating pressure or temperature range, a settling or stabilization time requirement, or certain methods of averaging measurement results. The lab’s ability to control these factors within these limits is a key part of achieving the accuracy specification of the standard.

A set of operating assumptions is also applicable to the DUT itself. For example, calibrating the DUT outside of its specified flow range may reduce the accuracy or repeatability of the measurement reported by the DUT. Such DUT measurement results may reduce the calibration confidence when the result is compared to the standard’s measurement.

In comparison, TUR is commonly defined as “Accuracy of the DUT / Uncertainty of the Measurement Ensemble”. The term measurement ensemble refers to the other equipment and processes used to compare the DUT’s measurement to the standard. In a flow calibration, factors such as flow profile, calibration media, connecting volume, and others will also impact flow measurement technologies in numerous ways. It may only be practical to quantify TUR after validation testing of each unique calibration system.

In the end, these ratios are often helpful tools for users that design and manage calibration processes. Some accreditation standards include explicit definitions for these values that are required to be used for all accredited calibrations performed in the lab, but relying solely on an accreditation standard’s prescribed TUR value may not provide a calibration result that is within the standard’s acceptance test limits for all calibrations performed in the lab. Any such inconsistencies should be reviewed and discussed with the responsible metrologist and/or the auditor used for the lab’s accreditation.

Notably, different industry associations also provide definitions for these ratios that are inconsistent with each other and are different than the calculations shown above, so confirming that the values are all found via the same methods is critical to making accurate comparisons. For best results, these ratios should be used as a small part of a comprehensive strategy that manages how measurement risk decisions are made in the lab.

Let’s talk DryCal!

Talk with one of our experts to get your questions answered and see how we can help you solve your calibrator pain points.


accuracyconnecting volumeFlow MeasurementMetrologyratiostandardTARtestTURuncertainty
About the author

Brandon Hansen

Brandon is the DryCal Sales Manager at Mesa Labs. Prior to joining the team at Mesa, Brandon worked with several manufacturers and integrators of instrumentation for flow, pressure, temperature, and numerous other process control applications. Known as “The Flow Demon” in some dark corners of the automation world, Brandon now works with Mesa’s clients to drive value through their operations using DryCal primary gas flow calibration standards. He holds a Bachelor’s degree focused on Industrial Control Technology from Devry University, and is an active member in both the ISA and SEMI organizations.

Related posts
Newest Gas Flow Calibrator
FlexCal, the Newest Portable Gas Flow Calibrator
April 3, 2018
Turnkey Solutions
Mesa’s MFC Calibration Solutions
March 13, 2018
The Dangers of Silica Sand
Mined Silica Sand Causing Discord Among Neighbors
February 6, 2018
New Service Center
Mesa Has Partnered with Quest Technologies to Establish a New International Service Center in China!
January 17, 2018
Visit us at the National Air Quality Conference!
December 28, 2017
ML-One End of Sales & Service
ML-One End of Sales & Service
November 1, 2017
Have Questions?

Contact Us!

Free Download!
Quickly capture flow data in real-time with our free DryCal Pro software

Get it now! >>>

Need Calibration?
Make sure your data is defensible with our expert calibration service

Learn more >>>

Sign up for our newsletter!
Stay up to date on industry news, new products and product updates with our FlowLines newsletter

Featured Articles
  • Precise, Primary Measurements
    CTS Cincinnati Test Systems, Inc.; a Case Study
    February 22, 2017
  • 2017 PQAO Training
    Supporting Air Quality Specialists
    February 2, 2017
  • OSHA Respirable Crystalline Silica Rule
    New OSHA Respirable Crystalline Silica Rule
    November 3, 2016
About Us
  • About Mesa Labs
  • Associations & Organizations
  • Upcoming Events
  • Newsletter
  • Corporate Site
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms & Conditions
Contact
Mesa Laboratories, Inc.
10 Park Place.
Butler, NJ 07405

973.492.8400
biosdrycal@mesalabs.com

Find us on:

FacebookTwitterYouTubeLinkedinWebsite
© 2016 Mesa Labs, Inc. All rights reserved.